First visit

What to order at Jon & Vinny's the first time

A salad, the Spicy Fusilli, one pizza and soft serve. The order for two, with prices.

{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"Article","headline":"What to order at Jon & Vinny's the first time","description":"A salad, the Spicy Fusilli, one pizza and soft serve. The order for two, with prices.","image":"https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/6ab5ab8b79a7d70ef89761af/6ab5acf4e6de3bf68e5814eb_fusilli-plate.jpg","author":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Jon & Vinny's"},"publisher":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Jon & Vinny's"},"dateModified":"2026-10-06","mainEntityOfPage":"https://jon-vinnys.webflow.io/guides/first-visit"}

3 minute read

Jon & Vinny's

The menu is long. For two people on a first visit, this is the order. Prices are the same at every location.

Start with the Gem Lettuce

Gem lettuce with a spicy Calabrian chili dressing, parmesan and breadcrumbs. $18.25. Order it first and share it while the pizza is in the oven.

The Spicy Fusilli

Vodka sauce, basil, parmesan. $24.95. Every pasta on the menu is made in house. One order between two is enough with a pizza on the table. See the Spicy Fusilli.

One pizza

The Brooklyn Dodger is the plain one: mozzarella, parmesan, oregano, basil, tomato, garlic. $23.20. If you want pepperoni, the Little Nats has pepperoni, caciocavallo, tomato and oregano. $27.55. The LA Woman comes with local burrata served cold on top. $25.20.